Calculating Enclosure Costs Relating to a Re-built Party Fence Wall

Sunday, 13th April 2014
Party Wall Questions | Party Walls | Surveying

A question came up on a recent party wall job which led to an interesting debate on what the section 11(11) expenses should cover when one owner re-builds a party fence wall as a party wall and the other owner later makes use of it.

Section 11(11) of the Act states that:

Where use is subsequently made by the adjoining owner of work carried out solely at the expense of the building owner the adjoining owner shall pay a due proportion of the expenses incurred by the building owner in carrying out that work; and for this purpose he shall be taken to have incurred expenses calculated by reference to what the cost of the work would be if it were carried out at the time when that subsequent use is made.

It normally falls to the appointed surveyors to agree what is covered before going on to calculate the cost of the works at current rates.

The award that we were agreeing related to a single storey rear extension to a terraced house in Fulham. Approximately 5 years previously the adjoining owner had built a similar extension and as part of that work had demolished a 1500mm high brick shared boundary wall and re-built it as a Building Regulation compliant cavity wall also astride the boundary i.e. a party wall.

Being a party wall it was available for the current building owner to use as party of their proposed extension. As adjoining owner’s surveyor I discussed 3 possible options with the building owner’s surveyor.

That the section 11(11) costs be based upon the cost of constructing:

  • The whole wall that is being enclosed upon including the foundation.
  • The whole wall but not the foundations.
  • The whole wall minus the area of the original party fence wall.

I argued the case for Option 1 but the building owner’s surveyor maintained that he’d agreed many similar awards on the basis of Option 3 over the years.

After an extended phone call (all good natured I should add!) we agreed to put the question to the selected Third Surveyor for an informal opinion.

His opinion was ‘I would tend to go with 3. It could include allowance for the better foundations if appropriate’.

As it was an informal opinion we didn’t get any further explanation but I took ‘better foundations’ to mean new foundations (as that’s what were constructed) whereas the building owner’s surveyor took it to mean a 60% contribution (as the original foundations, which were grubbed out, were 400mm deep and the new foundations were 1000mm deep).

In the end we agreed that the section 11(11) expenses should cover the new wall minus the area of the original party fence wall but including the whole of the new foundation. It still didn’t seem logical to me but having had an informal opinion from the Third Surveyor there was little point in risking a formal referral on the same point.

I later put the question to an expert legal panel made up of 2 specialist property barristers and 1 specialist property solicitor at one of our local party wall forum meetings and they were unanimous that option 1 should have been adopted. Which just goes to show that even when you’re sure you’re right you have to compromise when you’re outnumbered.

Should you require advice on a party wall matter you are welcome to contact us via email or on 020 7183 2578.

Had a Level 2 survey carried out recently, excellent service, clear and concise report delivered on time. Great service from start to finish from our first point contact Joanne to the surveyor Justin. Happily recommend.
Fantastic company, very professional and provided an excellent service for my help to buy property valuation.
Excellent service!

We booked a survey with Peter Barry Surveyors for the purchase of a home. Maianh was very quick to respond to our initial email and all follow up conversations. They also set us up with a pre-survey phone call with David Breeze (surveyor) who took the time to explain how the survey is conducted. They arranged access to the property directly with the realtor, and we received the report 4 working days later, after which we had another call with David to discuss the report and explained to us what the next steps were. We are now in the process of conducting the specialist surveys (with other companies) as per their recommendation.

Very helpful, very friendly, and professional.
Response from the owner:Thank you very much for your excellent review! We are delighted that you found our team to be helpful, friendly, and professional throughout the process, and I will certainly share your comments with Maianh and David. Thank you for choosing Peter Barry Surveyors!
I received an excellent service, with great communication, this company is fantasic, very helpful and highly recommended.
Response from the owner:Thank you for your recommendation.
Peter Barry just completed a party wall award for us in preparation for works on our property. They will fast, reliable and kept us in the loop throughout the process
Response from the owner:We appreciate your review Mr Pemberton, thank you.
We used Peter Barry Chartered Surveyors for our Party Wall matters while carrying out structural works on our house. They were efficient, professional, and easy to communicate with. Amrita Johal was our main point of contact.
Response from the owner:Thank you for taking the time to share your experience, Silvia. We are thrilled to hear that you found our team at Peter Barry Chartered Surveyors efficient, professional, and easy to communicate with during your Party Wall matters. Amrita Johal will be delighted to hear your kind words. If you need any assistance in the future, please do not hesitate to reach out.
Call Now Button